There Will Never Be A Perfect Tyre For F1
The Pirelli tyres received unwanted attention and criticism from most drivers at the 2018 Spanish Grand Prix. Here’s a summary of who said what and how Formula 1 has almost never had the perfect tyre to go racing on!Â
In the world of Formula One, the topic of tyres has received an unfair share of attention and possibly criticism ever since someone realised that tyres are a must-have to go racing! In fact, despite all the engineering and research, thereâ€™s seldom a tyre thatâ€™s perfect for everyone to go racing on.
My memory takes me back to the days of the tyre war eraÂ â€“ Bridgestone vs. Michelin as an obvious point of reference. In fact, Formula Oneâ€™s current sole official tyre supplier, Pirelli, too hasnâ€™t had it easy despite having no competition in the sport. Their tyres went from being highly degrading to being extra durable to somewhere in between and now at the 2018 Spanish Grand Prix, the Pirelli P-Zero tyres came under new fire and criticism from the drivers.
The first point of criticism came from Ferrariâ€™s Sebastian Vettel, who claimed that Pirelli changed their tyres after a request from Mercedes and Red Bull Racing. â€œObviously we have different tyres because Pirelli reacted to the issues Mercedes had and Red Bull had in testing, so weâ€™ll see how that goes,â€ he said.
However, when Mercedesâ€™ drivers (Valtteri Bottas and Lewis Hamilton) were quizzed about Pirelli favouring Mercedes, they had an interesting response. Bottas wondered, â€œWhy would they want to help us?â€, while Hamilton joked that â€˜that (the help) would be niceâ€™ and shrugged off the question as a â€˜stupidâ€™ one.
In fact, Vettel sang the same â€˜tyre tuneâ€™ pre and post racing, indicating that tyres were the â€˜biggest changeâ€™ for Ferrari despite a number of other upgrades on their car. â€œI think we struggled a little bit over the course of the weekend with the tyres, they changed but they changed for everyone. So our ambition has to be that weâ€™re better off rather than worse off,â€ confided Vettel post-race.
In our talking points from the race, we had pointed out how Vettelâ€™s medium tyre stint could go only half as long as Bottasâ€™ stintÂ â€“ a fact that should worry Ferrari. The bad news for Ferrari is that the current Pirelli tyre (which has a reduced tread by 0.4mm) will be used for the races in France and Great Britain as well. So the earlier they get used to it, the better.
The second point of criticism came from the other drivers who voiced their criticism about the current Pirelli tyres too. Hamilton explained, â€œWhether you give us more rubber or less rubber, they appear to be a lot harder than last year. I know they (Pirelli) went softer but I think itâ€™s more so because the working range is far narrower than it was last year â€“ and so you give it everything on an out-lap and you still don’t have your tyres in the window. And they heat the tyres up in the blanket. This year theyâ€™re just too hard. Thatâ€™s why everyone struggles. I donâ€™t understand why they worked in Australia and havenâ€™t worked ever since and today we have them working.â€
Strangely enough, in the qualifying session of the Spanish Grand Prix, the Mercedes drivers used the super-soft (the softest compound for the weekend) for their timed laps, whereas the Ferrari drivers used the soft tyres (the second softest compound) for theirs. This is after both Vettel and Kimi Raikkonen botched their first timed lap on super-soft tyres. Unexpectedly, Vettelâ€™s fastest lap on the softs was a little over a hundredth of a second slower than Hamiltonâ€™s fastest lap on the super-soft.
Raikkonen further explained, “Sometimes it works for one team better than others. It’s pretty difficult to say how different it would have been had we had normal tyres.”, indicating after that the change impacted the super-soft tyre more than the soft.
McLarenâ€™s Stoffel Vandoorne said, â€œIn qualifying, everyone nearly ran all three compounds because it was hard to make out which was actually the quickest tyre on the circuit.â€ He wished that Pirelli offered a bigger spread between the different tyre compounds â€“ one that would probably make the races more interesting.
To cite Pirelliâ€™s case, the decision to alter the tread was taken after tyres ended up overheating at this yearâ€™s pre-season tests in Barcelona. Such decisions have been taken in the past (with the FIA in the loop) in 2011 and 2012 to counter the impact of new asphalt at a particular circuit. In April (at the Bahrain Grand Prix), Pirelli had sought the FIAâ€™s nod to alter the tyres for the newly resurfaced circuitsÂ â€“ Circuit de Catalunya, Paul Ricard and Silverstone.
While there is enough meat in both sides of the story, we may be able to assess the impact of these altered tread tyres only after the 2018 British Grand Prix â€“ once the regular tread tyres of Pirelli return. In the first four races of the season (till Spain), it seemed that Ferrari had a better understanding of the Pirelli tyres, while Mercedes were struggling. Irrespective, it seems that the tyre saga will continue with every other season, whether it is Pirelli, Michelin or any other manufacturer and whether it is for treads, compounds and variation of compounds; so long as they donâ€™t complain about the shape of the tyres!
This post was first published on Firstpost